Measuring the Return Loss of a Coaxial filter with an RTL Key , a Noise Generator an SWR Bridge , some software and a laptop

I ended now to test the possibility  to measure the Return Loss of a coaxial filter with some simple tools , like an RTL Key , a Noise Generator and a SWR Bridge , a software and a laptop .

I have used the following setup : 

And two different software : 

A) HDSDR ( that we already have used in three video for pointing satellites , measuring the satellite Beacons and check and measure in the FM band ) : https://www.hdsdr.de/
B) SATSAGEN from Alberto Ferraris : https://www.albfer.com/satsagen-download-page/

The results are in the following pictures : 

HDSDR : Much faster , but easy to saturate , limited span and limited markers possibilities





SATSAGEN  : Much slower , but difficult to saturate , no limited in higher span , big facilities on markers 



At the end , at these frequencies and for these amplitude ranges , with SOME PATIENCE AND SKILLS, the results are quite "similar" to that of a professional HP instrument as follow : 



Of course there are big limitations due to the Range of Visualization  that an RTL KEY ( that works with 8 bit ) can handle ( around 40dB) respect a professional  Spectrum Analyzer ( 100dB) and also the RTL KEY receive spurious signals and images . We have to take off all the AGC of the RTL Key to make measurements .

See for instance signals displayed  with a range of 100dB and the range of 40 dB in evidence .




ALSO TAKE INTO ACCOUNT THAT THE POWER OF THE NOISE LEVEL OF THE GENERATOR IN THE SMALL BAND IS VERY LOW .
 TYPICALLY - 50 dB DOWN RESPECT TO A NORMAL VNA .
THIS MEANS THAT THE MEASUREMENTS ARE EASILY AFFECTED FROM NOISE AND ALSO FROM INTERFERENCES FROM THE FM BAND SIGNALS ! 
NOT EASY TO PERFORM IN A CROWDED SITE .
DOUBLE SHIELDED CABLES ARE A MUST ANYWAY !


Claudio Re 


Commenti

Post popolari in questo blog

WHY USE THE ONE PORT RETURN LOSS MEASUREMENT INSTEAD OF THE TWO PORT TRANSMISSION LOSS MEASUREMENT

HOW TO REPAIR THE LNB POWER SUPPLY ON THE SAT RECEIVERS PROFLINE TRSrm

HOW TO ADD A FAN OR TO CHANGE ONE IN THE PROFLINE TRSrm RECEIVERS OR TO CHANGE A POWER SUPPLY